New Super Mario Bros. Wii Play Together

by Tom Kerkhof (and Geert van Ostaden)

New Super Mario Bros. Wii (NSMB from now on) is basically the sequel to the original New Super Mario Bros. on the Nintendo DS. The catch is, as we are all constantly made aware of by any form of advertisement Nintendo throws at us, that we can play this game with up to four players simultaneously. I know you could play four player games on the DS version, but you were never able to traverse through the levels of the main game with more than a single player. On this Wii sequel, you can.

And it is this feature, and possible this feature alone that can possibly make NSMB stand out from other platform games, or even Mario games.
I think it should be noted that NSMB is by no means a bad game – in fact, the single player is of that trademark, familiar high quality you’d expect from a Nintendo title – it’s just that it’s not what it was made out to be. For me, playing the game with four players isn’t as fun as I thought it could be – not by a long shot.
The main reasons for this are some minor annoyances that don’t do the game any justice and should really be fixed to make a better game. For instance, it is very easy to kill off your fellow players. I can honestly say it’s easier to kill them off then it is to truly help them. Now I would be the first person to admit that annoying your fellow players a bit is good fun, but it can really spoil the game in the long run. As such, I don’t understand why Nintendo made these settings both the default and without alternative. Were it possible to switch off some of the more hindering features, like how your character treats your fellow players as obstacles, or how the ‘death’ of your partners hinders your movement for a second due to its animation.

Then there is the bubble. I would love the bubble, were it not for the fact that it is sometimes too easy to accidentally activate it. Also, being able to save yourself as long as your partner is fine, perhaps makes the game a tad too easy, a feat its predecessor suffered from. As it stands, I merely like the idea of the bubble.

Of course, most of these problems are mostly absent in the versus (or ‘Coin’) mode, where the only objective is to collect as many coins as possible to win. In this mode, it’s a free-for-all and each player is allowed to hinder the other players as much as they can. However, the goal in this game is perhaps unsuited for this kind of game play. There is no way to ‘steal’ other players’ coins; you just have to collect as many coins as you possibly can. In some levels, it is thus very hard to stop players who already managed to collect enough – or many – coins. A shame, really, since I would bet some good money on this mode being an absolute hit, had it been refined a bit more.

In the end, this mostly means I think NSMB disappointed me a little. I though the concept of playing a classic Mario game would be a unbelievably good one, but it turns out it is merely a mildly entertaining one (or possibly an annoyingly frustrating one). Had Nintendo fixed some of the problems I listed before, then perhaps the game would have been great. In that case, I would even forgive the game its complete lack of any online support, a feature I think is sorely missed in a game of this day and age, especially when it tries to profile itself as a multiplayer game.

What remains is the excellent single player that takes elements from many classic Mario games and, like its predecessor, is an excellent addition to the library of Mario games. Admitted, it lacks the ‘fresh’ feel of its cousin on the DS, but it still has everything you loved about Mario. I just really miss the Multiplayer mode that could be so awesome, but even that mode is at least enjoyable, so in the end NSMB turned out to be a fine addition to the Wii library.